Farmers can be prosecuted for damaging short stretches of river, but when will water companies be held accountable for their actions, asks Andrew Livingston
Before and after images of the destruction of the River Lug by farmer John Price. Images: Environment Agency / Natural England
From childhood we learn that living organisms need water to grow. Obviously, then, water is quite a big deal in agriculture. Farmers need clean, good quality water to help grow their crops and hydrate their animals. Recently, news broke of a Herefordshire farmer, John Price, sentenced to 12 months imprisonment for irreparably damaging the River Lug, which passes through his land. The images are horrific. The beautiful stretch of river now looks like a canal after he ripped out and felled 95 bankside trees before dredging the river and creating a hard-standing area along the banks. Once again, farmers are negatively portrayed in the news. Mr Price’s previous record, detailed to the court, dates back 35 years, and shows his attitude to environmental legislation as it affects farmers. His latest actions were partly in breach of the 2018 Farming Rules For Water, which were introduced to reduce and prevent diffuse water pollution from agricultural sources. His is the first prosecution under those rules. I hope the farming community takes note – although only a minority would have acted as Mr Price did.
Farmer John Price was sentenced to 12 months in prison and ordered to pay £600,000 prosecution costs. A Restoration Order was also imposed. Image: Herefordshire Wildlife Trust
Raw sewage
The Rivers Trust states that only 14 per cent of England’s rivers are in good ecological health – and this includes 85 per cent of the entire world’s precious chalk streams (more than 40 chalk streams are found in Dorset and Hampshire). Every single one of England’s rivers fails to meet chemical standards. Rivers are being damaged and compromised not with diggers and chainsaws, but with raw sewage. Nationally, water companies are not doing enough to protect rivers from the sewage leaking into the fragile ecosystems – and nobody is holding them accountable. Last year, four Wessex Water bosses received eye-watering bonuses for hitting targets relating to the protection of the environment – in spite of many reports of sewage in the Wessex Water region’s rivers.The company’s chief executive, Colin Skellett, received £61,548 from a total bonus of £189,500 last year ‘for meeting environmental targets’, despite Wessex Water’s environmental rating in fact dropping from four stars to two.
The Parrett and Yeo Phosphate Pollution Study, which tests water quality in the River Parrett – flowing from Cheddington in West Dorset to Bridgwater Bay in Somerset – has consistently found harmful levels of phosphates. Wessex Water has blamed farmers but the study found that phosphate levels in the river never dropped, even when the streams entirely dried up during the summer months. The report suggests instead that the main sources of phosphate in the Parrett are the 11 sewage treatment plants whose outflows enter the river. None has a phosphate removal stage, and the report suggests that they account for more than 90 per cent of the phosphates entering the river. The study also shows that where farmers follow DEFRA guidelines for farming near water, phosphate run-off into local watercourses is in fact almost undetectable. If farmers are being charged with breaches of the new Rules and other environmental legislation, is it not time for water companies to be held equally accountable for the quality of the water in the rivers for which they are responsible? The Rivers Trust has produced an interactive map here, showing where the sewerage network discharges both treated sewage and overflows of untreated sewage and storm water into rivers in England and Wales in 2022. It’s all too easy to blame little farmers rather than to take on the big companies. It has recently been announced that the government can fine water companies an unlimited amount for polluting rivers, with the money being used for the restoration of the waterways. It’s a start.
As most people know, we headed to Mayfair this month for the swish awards do. As a tiny team, just to be shortlisted for Regional Publication Of The Year – to be considered among the top three regional titles in the country – was an honour. On the night we didn’t win, but did receive a Highly Commended accolade, one of only four on the night. This was beyond anything we expected – we were thrilled just to be in the room (and suspect we were the only ones there who had actually paid for their own seat…). In other news this month: After a seemingly unending spring of chilly greyness, summer seemed to rush at us in May. The blackthorn was lush, but the hawthorn has been positively frothing, hasn’t it? I have never seen the hedgerows so thick with white, it’s been utterly glorious. The buttercups and cow parsley too. Dorset has been flashing its prettiest ankle at us, and I’m happily woo-ed (though some are less happy about a council mow of said cow parsley – there are some disgruntled readers on the letters page this month). If you’ve been watching Springwatch (those poor little wren chicks! I was stricken!), then you might be feeling inspired to go and explore the AONB near Swanage. In a weird twist, our own best walk this month was from Studland. There are few public footpaths across the RSPB Arne reserve itself, for obvious reason, but the wider area’s stunning heathland is criss-crossed by them. If you’ve never explored it then now is the perfect time. We did a long walk (13 miles), but it’s very adaptable (it’s easy to cut the route to your own length – the map’s on p50) – and also very flat! We thoroughly recommend going, it’s simply beautiful, and we’d go now, before the summer hoardes arrive. Lastly, in a quick double answer to current FAQs in my inbox: Mochi, our son’s fifth-floor-window-diving cat, is doing amazingly. Her cast is finally off, she’s still limping but getting around beautifully. And no, I have not yet gone mug shopping. But I am thrilled by the number of people who got in touch to share that they also have a specific mug for every time of day/type of drink/mood. It’s the only way. Finally, I have a kickboxing grading tomorrow. I am feeling The Fear… but I love the sport, and work hard at progresing (if I pass tomorrow I’ll be just two away from a black belt). I only started it to spite my teenagers (no, really), and though I guarantee my body is the exact opposite of what you picture when you think ‘kickboxer’ it always brings me joy. Even if my creaking bones and weeping joints keep pretending I’m far too old for this nonsense.
PS – the photography submissions were SO strong this month, we’ve even changed the design of the back page to squeeze in just-one-more. Don’t miss it!
Thank you I would like to put in your magazine a big heartfelt thankyou. My brother collapsed in Gillingham surgery Monday 22nd. Help was there immediately, but although they worked on him he couldn’t be bought back. As a family we would like to thank everyone who helped him, it shows what great service we have in Dorset. Thankyou Melvie Martin & family
Rage against the mow I’m writing with a heavy heart and a dollop of shock about the premature trimming of our grass verges surrounding Sturminster Newton. Right during our cherished “No Mow May”. It seems the council, bless them, might’ve misplaced their calendars! Our lovely local wildlife relies on this period, and the council’s actions seem to sidestep the importance of this initiative. It’s like putting a full stop in the middle of a sentence, it just doesn’t make sense! We need to ponder the cost of such haste on nature’s precious cycle. We’re expecting a bit of clarity here, as well as an assurance that our “No Mow May” will be left undisturbed in future. I’m sure many of us would be pleased to see our council showing more regard for these matters. Sarah G, Sturminster Newton
I wish to voice my anger at what I presume are the actions of our council. It’s been so disheartening to witness the early cutting of our grass verges around the Sturminster Newton’s perimeter – sad at any time of year on unnecessary road stretches, but utterly unwarranted during “No Mow May”. Worse was to come however. Every morning I drive through the village of Hammoon. Every day in recent weeks I have gloried in the stunning shoulder-high swathes of cow parsley which have adorned the lane verges. They have neither impeded my vision, nor can I conceive that the lush thick verges of tall straight-growing plants have caused any other road user any safety issues. And yet these too have been subject to a ground-level mow in the last few days. I am horrified and enraged at this senselessness. The month of May is a critical period in our UK ecology – we choose it for no mowing for a reason. Wildflowers and grasses are in full bloom, providing vital habitats and food sources for insects, spiders, snails, small mammals and birds. By allowing the verges to grow, we ensure the survival of our local flora and fauna, supporting pollinators essential for our ecosystem’s health. I implore the council to reconsider their actions and respect our commitment to preserving and enhancing local biodiversity. Alan Watts, by email
On unintended consequences I am writing in support of Andrew Livingston’s thought-provoking piece on the delicate balance of biodiversity in the UK’s struggling ecosystems (The law of unintended consequences, May 23). The topic is a critical one, especially given the dire state of many of our native species and the implications of human actions on their survival. Andrew’s focus on the issue of legal protections, such as for raptors, and the unintended consequences of the, was interesting. While it is essential to protect threatened species, we must indeed acknowledge the ripple effects such interventions may have on the entire food chain. A stronger focus on habitat construction than on specific-species protection to enhance biodiversity. It would lead to a more sustainable balance in our ecosystems without disadvantaging other species in the process . The “law of unintended consequences” rings so true here. As we strive to protect and foster wildlife, we must remain vigilant to the complex dynamics of our ecosystems. James Smith, Sherborne
On the protesters In response to the letter by M. Holderness of Charlton (The BV, May 23), I share his concerns about the widespread dismissal of climate activists’ efforts. The urgency and severity of the climate crisis demand far-reaching, revolutionary changes, and I appreciate that activists are working to convey this message. It is true that climate activism is often met with antagonism, and its strategies can be seen as inconvenient or disruptive. However, the primary goal of such activism is to stir conversation and incite action, which, judging by the attention these movements have received, has been successful. The fact that we’re now discussing these issues more openly is evidence of the impact these protests have had. Scientific warnings about the catastrophic implications of climate change have been falling on deaf ears for decades. Far far too long. Consequently, the need for dramatic action to reverse the effects of climate change has become critical. It’s not about causing public disorder but about sounding the alarm to save our planet! I hope that more people will understand the desperate circumstances that have led to these protests and see them not as a nuisance but as a necessary wake-up call. The “revolution” Holderness speaks of should be seen not as an act of rebellion, but as an urgent call to action to ensure a sustainable future for our planet. Ellie Holding, Sherborne
On the digital business In response to Susan N’s letter from Blandford (The BV, May 23), I wholeheartedly concur with her perspective. As we advance further into the digital age, it is imperative for businesses, irrespective of their establishment date, to adapt and evolve with the changing times. It is understandable that some long-standing businesses might find the transition to digital platforms challenging. However, the advantages of such a move significantly outweigh the potential discomfort of adapting to new tools and technologies. Susan aptly pointed out the valuable opportunities for audience engagement, brand awareness, and promotion provided by social media platforms. There is ample help available in terms of training and resources for businesses seeking to improve their digital presence. The ability to harness digital platforms is no longer an optional extra but a crucial component of business survival in today’s highly competitive market. It’s been here for a generation now. The time has come for all businesses, irrespective of their size or establishment date, to embrace the digital era fully. By doing so, they not only stay relevant and attractive to new customers but also ensure their own continued growth and success. Ruby P (aged 62, and writing on my iPad!), by email
On disposable barbecues Your article on disposable barbecues (May 23) made alarming reading. Despite the horrific consequences, how is it that disposable barbecues remain readily available in the market? From instigating wildfires to contaminating the soil, endangering wildlife and simply causing sever burns, the threat these items pose is significant. While I am encouraged by the actions taken by Dorset Council, Litter Free Dorset, and responsible retailers such as Southern Co-op in raising awareness and removing disposable barbecues from their shelves, I believe more stringent measures are needed. Why can’t disposable barbecues be banned? Is it not justifiable to consider an all-out prohibition? We must strive for long-term changes. Convenience should never supersede safety and environmental responsibility. Anna B, by email
Every month we receive pet pictures which are submitted for the Reader’s Photography pages. It’s rare for them to make the photography pages, but we always feel a little guilty – they’re good pets, they deserve their own recognition. Every month we’ll now pick our favourite. Would you like your pet to be featured? Just send to [email protected]. Please be sure to include your pet’s name, age, and a couple of fun details about them.
The 39th Volunteers’ Week runs from 1st to 7th June, joining thousands of charities and voluntary organisations across the country in recognising the contribution volunteers make. The Blackmore Vale Partnership (BVP) is gearing up to celebrate their Health Champion volunteers who work with local GP practices to provide community support. During Volunteers’ Week, a member of the wellbeing team from the BVP will be holding a drop-in at The Exchange in Sturminster Newton, during their regular Country Market between 9.30 and ll.30am. It’s a great opportunity to have a chat over a cuppa and find out more. Jackie Monckton, Social Prescriber says: ‘Our volunteers provide a range of essential support in our local community: groups for bereavement, carers support, menopause and Parkinson’s. They have established Community Larders, assist with community clinics for older people and providing opportunities like Coffee Companions, Wellbeing Walking and more.’ Rowan Chambers, a Volunteer Health Champion, says ‘I find volunteering incredibly rewarding. It really has been one of the best things I have ever decided to do.’ For more information on available activities or to find out how to get involved yourself, simply contact the wellbeing team for a chat on 01747 856786.
We know, we’re the perfect excuse for a long glass of something cold and putting your feet up in a shady spot of the garden. It’s not loafing, it’s ‘catching up on the news’. You’re so welcome.
In the June issue:
Farmers can be prosecuted for damaging short stretches of river, but when will water companies be held accountable for their actions, asks Andrew Livingston
From rural countryside to critical care: Cllr Jane Somper’s massive job. Tackling many of Dorset’s challenges, most people are unaware of the importance, scope and complexity of Jane’s multi-faceted role
You just can’t get the staff… The UK’s first post-Brexit trade deals begin amid agricultural industry concerns and severe labour shortages.
Where can you go on a £2 bus fare? What does the bus price cap mean for people in Dorset – and just how far can you actually go?
Two staples of Sturminster Newton celebrate 50th anniversaries this month. In ‘From avocado baths to the Michelin Guide: Plumber at 50’, Richard and Alison Prideaux-Brune share the fascinating and occasionally hilarious story of the early days of the restaurant with rooms. Just a week later on the other side of the Stour, Anne and Tony Smith came to Candy’s newsagents. As the traditional family-run newsagents celebrates its half-century, Anne and her son Ashley reflect on surviving industry shifts, local changes – and personal losses
Pack up a picnic and go to a play! Balmy summer nights are coming; it’s time to take the risk and book for one of the many open air plays coming to a garden or a field near you. Gay Pirrie-Weir has an extensive round up of the open air theatre in Dorset this summer. It’s time to book your tickets!
Two fascinating interviews in this episode; Jenny chatted with wildlife writer Jane Adams about the dawn chorus (and her efforts to hear a very disappointing one!), and also to market director Jules Bradburn about the brilliantly successful launch of the new monthly Independent Shaftesbury Market.
Wildlife writer Jane Adams grew up in the suburbs, and vividly recalls the first time she shared her morning tea with the waking birds ” In the past, I didn’t understand why people got so excited about the dawn chorus. Wasn’t it just a bunch of birds singing ridiculously early in the morning?”
Roger Guttridge tells the story of Dorset’s first newspaper and the ‘Sherborne Men’ who ‘rode Sherborne’ to distribute it
There’s a major new independent market in Shaftesbury – the launch event had more than 70 stalls, and was a resounding success with almost 6,000 people visiting. The monthly event will boost tourism and trade, says market director Jules Bradburn, who already runs the hugely popular independent Sherborne market which she has grown to 200 stalls. She spoke to Jenny about how it’s going, and about some of the incredible artisans, producers and traders that are finding a new audience.
Jim Bettle makes a living from an ancient craft, fuelling his passion for a more sustainable country. One of very few British charcoal producers, by the end of August he’ll produce more than 35 tonnes of sustainable British charcoal from within his North Dorset woodland ‘office’.
Despite Studland being one of the busiest tourist spots in Dorset, this route takes you away from the crowds across the quietly stunning heathlands that sit behind the famous beaches, right next door to RSPB Arne. If you’ve been watching Springwatch, you may just be feeling inspired to get out on those wild heathlands yourself.
Don’t be put off by the outlined length of the route – it’s truly endlessly adaptable. Tracks and paths criss-cross the whole area, meaning you can chop it to any length you choose.
There are very few public footpaths across RSPB Arne itself (understandably so), but that doesn’t mean the area can’t be explored. It is surrounded by beautiful heathland – and as the crowds all head to the beaches the heathlands generally remain peaceful even in the height of the season.
We walked the route on a hot Saturday in May; the roads towards Studland were busy enough, but if you’re planning on a visit during July and August, or a weekend in June and September, we’d suggest making an early start to avoid the traffic. We parked easily on the roadside – but again, we suspect this will be trickier in-season.
Spot Corfe Castle sitting in the distance, queen of all she surveys
The scenery and views are surprisingly varied along the route – the wide open gorse-filled heathland gives way to tall pine forests, and there are also sections through lush farmland, deciduous forest paths, one section gives a wonderful view of Corfe Castle and there of course plenty of stunning sea views across Poole Harbour.
The route itself is incredibly simple – all the paths are clearly marked, and it’s almost entirely flat walking. The final section is a gentle incline, but not one you really notice, even after 11 miles, as the views across the sea are so spectacular!
Do take lots of water on a hot day – there are some pleasantly shady sections, but also long stretches on open heathland which gives glorious views, but no respite from the sun.
Parts of the route are on popular cycle paths, so do keep an ear out for those.
And after a lot of rain the section before Sharford Bridge becomes quite boggy, so be prepared!
Joan Margaret Standerwick, formerly of Shaftesbury, passed away peacefully at Penhellis Nursing Home, Helston.
A dearly loved wife to the late Bob Standerwick, and much loved mum to Colin, Trevor, Carolyn & Kevin. A loving Nana, Great Nana & Great Great Nana to her 16 grandchildren, who will be sadly missed.
Dorset County Show is preparing for an event of unparalleled magnitude, making it the must-see event of the season. Creatures both large and small will be making their grand entrance, some for the very first time.
From Saturday, September 2nd to Sunday, September 3rd, the County Show promises to deliver exceptional value. For those who seize the early bird offer by midnight on Thursday, June 1st, tickets are available at a mere £17 – a substantial £6 off the gate price.
Dorset Axemen new attraction for 2023
This year’s event is pulling out all the stops. For fans of the equine, there’s the Heavy Horse Village, a tribute to the gentle giants of the horse world. Demonstrations of heavy horse logging will be presented by Dorset’s own Toby Hoad, a rare talent in this ancient art. Attendees can witness the age-old bond between man and horse, reminiscent of a partnership over 10,000 years in the making.
Adding a dash of spirited competition, Shetland pony racing will debut at the County Show. These energetic ponies, known for their speed and agility, are sure to impress spectators.
HH logging New attraction for 2023
Monster trucks are set to bring a different kind of horsepower to the County Show. The arrival of Big Pete and his sidekick, The Grim Reaper, will be announced by the roar of their engines as they dominate the showground in a spectacular display of mechanical power.
Livestock competitions offer another facet of entertainment, as the county’s finest rare breeds, cattle, pigs, goats and sheep vie for the title of County Show Champion.
All creatures great and small
The idyllic woodland area will be the backdrop for the famed Dorset Axemen, whose skills hark back to the era before modern machinery. Attendees will be treated to displays of rapid chopping and crosscut sawing, demonstrating the sheer physical strength of these traditional woodworkers.
The newly introduced Crafter’s Avenue invites onlookers to appreciate the finesse of Dorset’s finest craftspeople. Here, visitors can witness an array of heritage crafts, such as basket weaving, spinning, and whittling.
Gourmands will delight in the event’s gastronomical offerings. In the newly launched Food and Drink Area, the county’s best producers will present an array of local, British delights, catering to every palate. Following high demand, two Food Halls will be available to satisfy even the most discerning foodie.
Heavy horses
Show Organiser, James Cox, stated, “Our revised approach for this year highlights the very best of Agriculture, Countryside, Rural Life, and the outstanding Food, Drink, and Crafts that Dorset has to offer. We’re uniting Dorset – from coast to countryside, and across all towns – in a grand harvest celebration.”
Despite the ongoing cost-of-living crisis, the show offers a valuable experience for all, particularly as children attend for free. The 10.5 hours of entertainment make it an offer not to be missed.
