
Question: if you pay someone to do a job and they don’t complete it, should you be able to refuse to pay the whole bill? If you think ‘Yes, of course!’ then you might be interested in the recent small claims court action by Wessex Water against Caroline Dennett, one of Dorset’s hardest working and most inspiring environmental campaigners. Caroline has been refusing to pay the sewage treatment element of her water bill, on the basis that Wessex Water has obviously failed to adequately provide that service.
Unusually for a small claims court hearing, Wessex Water chose to have a Barrister present their case. The judge was complimentary about Caroline’s presentation of her own defence, and she was sympathetic to Caroline’s arguments. She also refused to award costs against her, but ultimately had to conclude that she had no option in law other than to uphold Wessex Water’s claim for payment of the withheld money.
So we consumers have no redress when our water company fails to adequately provide the service we pay them for. And because they have a monopoly, there are no alternative suppliers we can turn to. Unless and until the industry is properly regulated, the UK’s water privatisation rip-off will continue. More than 70 per cent of UK water company shareholders are now foreign interests. Wessex Water itself is 100 per cent owned by a Malaysian infrastructure conglomerate. The ten privatised water companies established in 1989 were effectively debt free – they now have debts of more than £60bn, while over £80bn has been paid out to shareholders. And all the while, sewage has increasingly fouled our precious watercourses and beaches. If more of its customers temporarily withheld payment for the waste treatment part of their water bills, the pressure might encourage Wessex Water to fulfil its contract with us. What do you think ?
Some farming methods also cause gross pollution of our waterways, for example factory farmed chickens. But here, fortunately, we consumers do have a choice. Cheap chicken doesn’t pay for the huge damage it does to our environment – damage that one way or another we all pay for. So we can choose not to eat it, can we not?
Ken Huggins
North Dorset Green Party