Fasting –Yes or No?

Date:

From ancient tradition to modern health strategy – expert Karen Geary looks at the science and her personal journey with fasting

In 2012, Michael Mosley popularised the 5:2 fasting diet (5 days normal eating, 2 days very low calorie). Mosley’s approach was based on research conducted into Alternate Day Fasting (ADF), and as a consequence fasting, or time-restricted eating (eating in a defined time period each day), became much more prominent.
For my entire adult life, I have tried every fasting practice; from short 14-hour overnight fasts to several days of water-only fasting. Over the years I have changed my views on fasting and what works. These are my insights into fasting well.
First, a note of caution. Fasting will vary according to individual health conditions and may not be right for everyone. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting fasting if you have a medical condition, or are unsure. Pregnant or breastfeeding women, those with eating disorders or medical conditions should avoid fasting.

Why fast?
Fasting is an ancient practice with a long history in different cultures. Today there are many approaches to time-restricted eating, each purporting benefits such as weight loss and broader benefits such as improved lipid levels, lowered blood pressure, improved mental health and remission of type 2 diabetes.
Fasting can be a powerful tool for accomplishing health-related goals. For weight loss, you naturally eat less calories. People who struggle to spread their calories during the day find it helpful to restrict intake to a specific period eg a later breakfast or skipping an evening meal. Insulin reduces because there is no or less calorie intake, which – given time and consistency – helps reduce blood sugar and improves lipid levels. Lowered blood pressure and improved liver markers are common. Potential mental health benefits and cognitive impacts of fasting are emerging – recent research has shown potential effects on brain health and mental clarity.

What the science says
Scientific literature on fasting is still evolving. I first researched it in 2015, and back then most of the research was on mice or young males.
The original 16/8 model (16 hours fasting, eight hours feeding) came from a study using mice – but it’s not exactly a valid comparison. A 16/8 fast for a mouse is the equivalent of several days fasting for humans!
There was less research on the elderly, women and post-menopausal women due to hormonal complexities, but more is becoming available. Even now, some research is not solid or has contradictory results, needing more studies using diverse populations. There is emerging research on fasting during chemotherapy, which I’m monitoring with interest.
Longevity is often associated with fasting – some claims are overstated but again there is always new research which I keep up to date with. .
The best way I judge the success of different fasting methodologies is to combine what the research says with my observations in clinic with clients. The sweet spot is finding the best approach for an individual, and not just sticking slavishly to the latest approach or trend. It must work around lifestyle and what can be achieved consistently.

  • Things I have learned:
  • Long term fasts (eg three day water fasts) can make you feel unwell and can contribute to lost muscle mass from lowered protein intake. I’ve yet to be convinced of the benefits vs. the misery inflicted.
  • It is hard (but not impossible), to hit a protein target on a 5:2 or ADF-style approach. This may affect muscle mass over the longer term.
  • A time-restricted eating window (eg 16/8 or 20/4) gives discipline and structure to those trying to manage their hunger and calories; in particular late night snacking.
  • Hypocaloric fasting – a very low calorie diet (like the 800 calories-a-day diet created by Michael Mosley, or the Fasting Mimicking Diet created by Valter Longo) – is not a true fast, but does help take away hunger pangs. If you are not metabolically healthy, it’s a great option, but the trade-off is likely lower muscle mass, so not something to do long term.
  • Fasting during the week preceding a menstrual cycle may exacerbate symptoms such as mood swings and cravings, so is probably best avoided or limited to a shorter window.
  • Key tips for fasters
  • Stay hydrated, and prioritise protein and plants during eating windows/non fast days.
  • Circadian rhythm fasting aligns eating patterns with the body’s natural cycle, emphasising earlier eating and a longer overnight fast. By syncing with the body clock it may improve digestion, sleep and weight management.
  • Begin gradually, shifting meal times earlier in the day and extending the fasting period. Start with a 12-hour fasting window and gradually increase it to 14-16 hours, allowing your body to adapt. Try to maintain a consistent eating schedule, as irregular eating patterns can disrupt the body’s circadian rhythm. Consistency helps regulate hunger cues and supports better metabolic function.
  • When breaking a longer fast, start with something light, perhaps a few nuts and fruit, before eating a large meal. Incorporate plenty of fruits, veggies, lean proteins and healthy fats.
  • On non-fasting days, don’t eat between meals, leaving 4-5 hours between eating. Three meals a day with no snacks sounds dull, but it avoids compromising any benefits of fasting.
  • Prioritise exercise, especially resistance exercise in order to maintain muscle.
  • Fasting with a friend (sounds like a wonderful chat-up line – Ed) is scientifically more successful.
  • Try apps like Zero or Fastic to help keep on track with your fasting. They provide excellent educational content and have great reminders.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

More like this
Related

Summer weight loss the easy way

Some topics come up again and again – nutritionist...

Celebrating Pride with pride

Finding your space: Dorset Mind volunteer Annabel Goddard looks...

How changing Stroke Pathways is known to save lives

Yeovil’s Stroke Unit controversy – amid the public debate,...

Get moving to boost your mood

Incorporating movement into your daily routine can really lift...